Friday, 23 October 2015

IMA demands amendments to the PCPNDT Act

IMA demands amendments to the PCPNDT Act

The PNDT Act came into being with the purpose of improving the altered sex ratio in India. It was further amended PCPNDT Act to regulate the technology used in sex selection. The Act banned preconception and prenatal sex determination. Its intent was to curb the actual act of sex selection and female feticide by regulating the use of ultrasound technology. 

WHO in its recent publication has clearly declared that restricting technology was not the way forward and there is a lot that still needs to be done in this direction. .

Despite the Act having been in existence for over 20 years, the altered sex ratio in India has not changed. Instead, the act has had two major negative consequences:

• In its current form, the implementation of the PCPNDT Act has deprived the community of life-saving and essential ultrasonography which has now become an extension of clinical practice for all specialties globally, being a well-known non-invasive, cost-effective and accurate diagnostic tool.

• The current PCPNDT Act has made it extremely difficult for ultrasound clinics to ensure complete enforcement. Doctors and other medical professionals are being put to extreme hardship while performing routine and essential scans. Due to this, many qualified doctors are opting not to do PNDT scans, thus creating a shortage of experts trained in ultrasonography.

Speaking on this issue, Padma Shri Awardee, A Marthanda Pillai – National President and Padma Shri Awardee, Dr K K Aggarwal – Honorary Secretary General and President HCFI in a joint statement said, “As the PCPNDT Act has not resulted in the improvement of the falling sex ratio, social rather than medical interventions will be required to handle this issue effectively. The Act is being used to punish doctors for minor offences such as clerical errors in the filling of forms, thereby resulting in doctors being prosecuted and ultrasound machines being seized and sealed. Collectively IMA has put together some amendments which are required to solve this crisis”.

IMA demands the following amendments:

• The Act needs urgent modification to allow unambiguous and easy interpretation. The “Rules” need to be simplified and implemented uniformly across the country, and adhoc changing of rules by each local authority should be strictly prohibited. New rules must be logical and should apply to the entire country only after due discussion with the representative bodies. Time should be given for implementation of the new rules.

• The Act is to be directed only towards Obstetric Ultrasound and not any other applications of ultrasonography.

• The word “Offence” under this act has to be clearly defined. The word Offence should only mean the “actual act of sex determination or female feticide”.

• All other clerical/administrative errors should be classified as non-compliance (and not an offence). Strict penalties can only be imposed for the actual act of sex determination or female feticide and not for other errors. There is a need to redefine “what amounts to sex determination” as mere evidence of clerical error does not amount to sex determination. “Imprisonment” rules should be for the offence (of sex determination or female feticide) & not for non-compliance.

• Inspections should be conducted yearly instead of every 90 days. No NGO can conduct “raids” on doctors’ premises and there should be no impediment to doctors doing their practice during inspections.

• Ultrasonologists should not be restricted to working in only two centers.

• The doctors should have the right to report on those seeking sex determinations and action must be initiated against them immediately.




How important it is to ensure physician’s wellbeing

For doctor’s cause: How important it is to ensure physician’s wellbeing and what can be its impacts on their patients?
Dr K K Aggarwal

The importance of physician’s wellbeing was the centre of discussion of the delegates at the annual General Assembly of the WMA in Moscow, which was held from 14th to 17th October. The expert panel saw the active participation of around 60 countries, stressing on how a few factors including biological, psychological and social problems experienced by physicians including mental illness, disabilities, occupational stress, burnout and any other chronic ailment can affect the efficiency of the doctor and as well as their patients.

As often discussed, a physician’s wellbeing is one of the most prominent factors contributing towards successful treatment of a patient. However, there is still not much clarity on this subject, but still this topic has been going back and forth in the discussions of the medical experts. They have spoken about the medical industry of each country needs to focus on encouraging ongoing research on physician’s health. Government should start supporting the conclusions based on the estimates and evidences that we already have. While it is always believed that physician’s follow the nitty-gritty of a healthy lifestyle, but some of them still suffer a lot of stress due to different reasons.

Reportedly, it has been observed that the highest rate of suicide is found amongst the medical professionals, especially physicians. Additionally, female doctor suicides significantly outnumber male doctor suicides.  The major factors accountable are the stress and strain one has go through in order to be a doctor and carry on in the medical profession. Due to the workload, doctors often end up getting managing and multi-tasking consistently. As a result, they get inadequate sleep, are forced to social isolation and are overworked. The government needs to take a step and start working on framing the necessary policies that will ease up the whole crisis for physicians and their patients as well.

Setting all the reasons aside, physicians tend to avoid seeking help in case they feel ill because they are concerned about the confidentiality of the information pertaining to them. They are seen as the role models by their patients and hence, they hesitate in opening up about their health problems. To eradicate this fear of information breach and excessive burden of external expectation on them, government should ensure that the physicians get the same right of confidentiality as any other patient when seeking and undergoing a treatment. The health care system may need to provide special arrangements for the care of physician-patients in order to uphold its duty to provide privacy and confidentiality. Prevention, early assistance and intervention should be available separately from any disciplinary process for them.

WMA states the factors that hinder the wellbeing of a physician:

·         The medical profession often attracts highly driven individuals with a strong sense of duty. Successfully completing the long and intense educational requirements often confers upon physicians a high degree of respect and responsibility in their communities. This external expectations burden often ends up burdening them with a lot more than an individual can take, hence, leading to stress. Also, the doctors, who are always looked up on as the ideals and role models prioritizing the care of others over care of self. And missing out on expectations often given them a feeling of guilt and selfish nature

·         Working conditions, including workload and working hours, affect physicians’ motivation, job satisfaction, personal life and psychological health during their careers. Sometimes, due to the extended working hours, they miss out on required sleeping hours and this eventually leads to their health deterioration

·         Physicians are often perceived as being immune to injury and diseases as they care for their patients. Physician who are employed by small organizations or who are self-employed may be at even a higher risk for occupational diseases and may not have access to health and safety programs provided by relatively large health care establishments. So, despite the size of a hospital or a clinic, the basic healthy practices and hygiene should be adopted for the help of both patients and doctors

·         Physicians in postgraduate education often confront emotionally challenging and traumatic situations including patients’ suffering, injury and death. Physicians may also be exposed to physical hazards like radiation, noise, poor ergonomics, and biological hazards like HIV, TB and hepatitis. All of this makes them more prone to the diseases which can degenerate their health both mentally and physically

·         Additionally, some of the physicians in postgraduate education and medical students, especially women can be victims of harassment and discrimination during their medical education.  And due to their position within the medical hierarchy, they may feel powerless to confront these behaviours. This leads to the frustration building up in their minds and causing a mental outbreak

·         Medical industry runners should work on potential obstacles, which restrict an ill physician from seeking care including denial, confidentiality issues, aversion to the patient role, practice coverage, fear of disciplinary action, potential loss of practice privileges, loss of performance based payment and the efficiencies of self-care.

·         Illnesses can include mental and behavioural health problems, burnout, communication and interpersonal issues, physical and cognitive problems and substance use disorders

According to WMA, a few steps immediately need to be followed including improved wellness promotion programs, prevention strategies and earlier intervention of symptoms in physicians can help mitigate the severity of mental and physical illnesses and help reduce incidence of suicide in physicians and medical students. 







Thursday, 22 October 2015

Protecting the girl child: What our rituals teach us

Protecting the girl child: What our rituals teach us

Dr K K Aggarwal


The 9-day Navratri fast is broken on the eight (ashtami) or the ninth (navami) day of Navratri by worshipping 8 or 9 girl children, of prepubertal age and older than 2 years. This ritual is called ‘kanya puja’.  

The tenth day of the festival is celebrated as Dussehra in the country as the day when Lord Ram killed Ravana. The burning of effigies of Kumbhkaran, Meghnath and Ravana symbolize killing of one’s tamas, rajas and ahankar denoting the victory of good over evil.

The nine girls worshipped during ‘kanya puja’ are regarded as the nine forms of ‘Devi’ or ‘Durga’ or mahashakti, which regulates creation, preservation and destruction on earth.
This ritual of ‘kanya puja’ not only has religious significance, it has social relevance too. With the increasing violence against female child in the form of female feticide, infanticide or sexual abuse, this ritual gives the message that every girl child needs to be protected from abuse of any kind, be it physical or mental.

A vrata or fast means ‘to vow’; it teaches self-control or control over desires. The festival of Navratri is the process of detoxification of body, mind and soul, at the end of which a person attains purification of soul and learns to exercise restraint. Since ages, this festival has spread the values and stresses the need to protect and take care of the girl child.

Happy Dussehra: Fighting your health demons for a healthy life!

Happy Dussehra: Fighting your health demons for a healthy life!

This Vijaydashmi, people should find ways to beat key lifestyle evils like stress, depression, insomnia, obesity, smoking, alcohol and drugs
New Delhi, 21st October 2015: Dussehra is one of the most important Hindu festivals, which marks the triumph of good over evil. During the festival, devotees worship Lord Rama, who ended the rule of Ravana thereby reinstating goodness in the World. Likewise, this Dusshera, each one of us should try and fight the evils within us for a healthy and long life.

A balanced state of mind and a healthy lifestyle can go a long way in preventing lifestyle diseases such as diabetes, hypertension, cardiac ailments and obesity. The life of the 21st century Indian is found plagued with evils such as unhealthy eating habits, a sedentary lifestyle, excessive stress, consumption of tobacco and alcohol. The time has come to reverse this trend and make necessary lifestyle changes. Simple everyday lifestyle modifications can do the trick.

Speaking about these, Padam Shri Awardee Dr. K K Aggarwal – Honorary Secretary General IMA and President HCFI said, “This Dusshera, we must take a pledge to eliminate evils like smoking and drinking from our lives. To restrict the consumption of food containing high levels of trans fat, sodium and refined sugar. We must deal with stress through a holistic approach and to do away with anger and negativity from our lives. Most lifestyle diseases are preventable and manageable, only when necessary precautionary measures are taken. We must work towards beating obesity, heart disease, hypertension and diabetes. Only when we do, will the true meaning of a victory of good over evil can be achieved.”

Some healthy alterations that one can make:

·         To avoid stress, you should start taking short breaks at regular intervals whenever working at the office or even at home. Eat foods like brown bread for carbohydrates instead of white bread, oranges and lemons for vitamin C and spinach for magnesium. A healthy diet and sufficient sleep help release chemicals like serotonin, which helps to reduce stress

·         More often than not, people think that smoking helps in reducing stress, which is nothing more but a myth. Excessive smoking aggravates blood pressure, increases heart rate and reduces the supply of the oxygen to the brain. You should immediately quit smoking for a disease free life

·         Alcohol is one of the most dangerous evils prevailing in our society; it is responsible for a plethora of medical ailments. Alcohol can worsen heart problems and cause cirrhosis of the liver. It triggers obesity and depression.

·         The majority of lifestyle diseases stem from our irregular and unhealthy eating habits. People who indulge in overeating and consume primarily junk food can develop long-term chronic diseases like diabetes, high blood pressure, heart issues due to increased cholesterol and obesity. A balanced diet is a key; consume healthy meals, which have the required nutritional meals you body needs to function efficiently. Consuming small but frequent meals, which contain a sufficient quantity of fruits and vegetables, is key. One should reduce the intake of high trans fat, sugar and sodium laden food.


·         Exercise daily; include a 5-minute brisk walk and a 10-minute stretching in your things to do list whenever you get time. Regularly exercising also helps keep a check on hypertension and obesity.

Non-violent and emphatic communication facilitates better treatment of patients

Non-violent and emphatic communication facilitates better treatment of patients

Effective Communication is the key to building relationships, businesses, a career and it equally affects everything in this universe. However, we often do not realize that in addition to just transmitting information, a good communication strategy also positively effects the outcome and if not done properly, it can lead to unwanted disruption and miscommunication.

An effective non-violent communications strategy can help medical professionals in their career and in the treatment of the patients. Communication forms a core part of every doctor-patient relationship. To effectively treat any chronic disease, it is important for the doctor to know in detail the medical history of the patient. A positive communications approach helps a patient feel at ease with his doctor encouraging conversation about lesser known factors  that can aggravate an individual’s heath deterioration like stress, depression or any other personal issues.

For patients suffering from lifestyle disorders like diabetes, heart disease, their relationship with their doctor is a life-long one. For successful lifestyle management of diseases, it is extremely important that the doctor has a detailed understanding of the patient and his tendencies so as to overcome hurdles effectively. In addition to this, it is also important that the patient trusts the doctors advice to be able to implement his suggestions.

Speaking on the issue, Padma Shri Awardee, Dr. K K Aggarwal – Honorary Secretary General IMA and President HCFI, “When medical professionals try to create emphatic surroundings for their patients, the patient satisfaction levels and improvement rates are found to be much higher. The three Cs of violent communication are – condemn, criticise and complaint. By eliminating these while interacting with one’s patient, a harmonious relationship can be established. Hostility, aggression, anger all are linked to directly or indirectly violent communication. The chances of a patient adhering to the lifestyle changes directed by the doctor are much higher if communicated to in a emphatic manner as opposed to in a stern and angry fashion.”

Nowadays, as such there is no special training given to the doctors or to physicians, on how to effectively create positive relationships with their patients. On one side a doctor is expected to be non-emotional when it comes to their patients and on the other emphatic. A clear professional relationship is ideal based on trust, honesty and direct communication.

In addition to this, non-violent communication also helps strengthen the relationship between medical practitioners and their subordinates. Doctors must address and interact with their colleagues with respect and should not condemn or criticize them in public or behind their back. Similarly if a positive relationship is established with one’s juniors, nurses, hospital staff, better healthcare delivery is guarantee.


Winning the Swine Flu Battle – H1N1 vaccine and its importance

Winning the Swine Flu Battle – H1N1 vaccine and its importance

Swine flu cases continue to be recorded from different parts of the country. Given this situation, basic prevention measures become essential. 

Swine Flu or H1N1 influenza is a viral respiratory infection, which strikes like a ‘common-cold' infection but is more severe in symptoms and the outcomes. The influenza virus mutates extremely fast and is highly infectious. The typical symptoms of Swine flu are a cough, sore throat, fever, headache chills and fatigue.

Speaking about this issue, Padma Shri Awardee Dr. A Marthanda Pillai – National President and Padma Shri Awardee Dr. K K Aggarwal, Honorary Secretary General and President HCFI in a joint statement said, Prevention of Swine Flu mainly involves taking simple precautionary steps while coughing and maintaining respiratory and hand hygiene. Respiratory hygiene involves maintaining a distance of at least 3 feet from a person who is coughing and sneezing. Proper cough etiquette demands that the infected person ensures that he or she covers their mouth and nose with a tissue while coughing or sneezing and then disposes of the tissue immediately to stop the disease from spreading to others. In a case where a tissue may not be available, it is best to cough and sneeze into one's upper sleeves and not in their hands or a handkerchief. Sneezing and coughing into one's hands/ using a handkerchief are reasons why the disease spreads at such a rapid pace. In addition to this, vaccination is recommended specially in high risk individuals.”

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has recently released its recommendations that all persons aged six months or older should receive H1N1 influenza vaccine. A priority list of population groups for vaccine administration should be followed, if the vaccine supply is limited. This includes pregnant women,
individuals from 6 months through 24 years of age, household contacts and caregivers of children younger than six months of age, individuals from 25 through 64 years of age with health conditions associated with increased risk of influenza complications and healthcare and emergency medical services personnel

Drug therapy: Recommendations

Antiviral therapy should be promptly given to
·         Children, adolescents, or adults with suspected or confirmed influenza infection and any of the following features
·         Illness requiring hospitalization
·         Progressive, severe, or complicated illness, regardless of previous health status
·         Suspected or confirmed influenza infection who were at high risk for complications including:
o   Children <5 years of age, particularly those <2 years of age
o   Adults ≥65 years of age
o   Pregnant women and women up to two weeks postpartum (including those who have had pregnancy loss)
o   Individuals with certain medical conditions

Antiviral therapy be started as soon as possible in patients who are severely immunosuppressed such as those receiving treatment for malignancies, hematopoietic or solid organ transplant recipients and present with an acute respiratory illness

Patients with morbid obesity (BMI >40) and possibly those with obesity (BMI 30 to 39) with suspected or confirmed pandemic H1N1 influenza A virus infection should be carefully evaluated for the presence of conditions that confer an increased risk of influenza complications. If any such conditions were present, treatment is recommended.




IMA urges the government to withdraw plans to start a Bachelor of Science in Community Health

IMA urges the government to withdraw plans to start a Bachelor of Science in Community Health


 The Indian Medical Association strongly objects the Government move to start BSc Community Health course under the National Board, to man sub-centers and empowering them to prescribe medicines.

Speaking about this issue, Padma Shri Awardee Dr. A Marthanda Pillai – National President and Padma Shri Awardee Dr. K K Aggarwal, Honorary Secretary General and President HCFI in a joint statement said, “Sub centers are the cornerstones of disease prevention activities and implementation of national health programs and not primarily meant to provide curative service except home remedies. The staff pattern in the sub center consists of one male and one female multipurpose health worker (JPHN/JHI/ANMs). The job description of these staffs is family welfare services, immunization, awareness, household visits, data collection regarding disease prevalence, and coordinating other national disease control programs. These staffs currently work under the supervision of a medical officer posted in PHC. For this purpose there is no need for a more qualified workforce. Posting the proposed BSc (Community Heath) graduates in sub centers will be a wrong human resource management”.

At the Sub Centre level, a more suitable workforce would be an ASHA worker with basic primary education and training. So the concept of posting paramedics at sub centers will be a gross waste of human resources and will be counterproductive for the purpose they are meant. The policy proposal on this is not based on ground reality and is conceptually wrong. The deployment of over qualified staff at sub centers will only increase the attrition rate. Entrusting the newly proposed BSc (Community health) graduates to manage very sensitive areas like child health within the health system may even worsen the situation. To leave the health of children and adolescents in the hands of ill-equipped personals is detrimental and may nullify the results of years of hard work that the country has put into reducing child mortality and morbidity

Moreover, if the Government’s intention is to produce health workers to work in sub centers, then why should such courses be conducted by the National Board of Examination (NBE)? In fact the NBE conducts postgraduate courses and not even undergraduate courses in modern medicine. Allowing these graduates to be registered under Medical Council will set a wrong practice.

IMA therefore, urges the Government to desist from the move to start BSc (Community Health) course.